The Irish presidency of the EU Council has put forward compromise language that could slow cuts to free carbon allowances for European industry. Reuters reported on the document on 15 November 2026, ahead of member-state discussions scheduled for Wednesday, 18 November. Steel, cement, chemicals and fertiliser producers are among the sectors potentially affected. This is a negotiating proposal, not an adopted Council position or a change already in force.

The European Commission proposed a broader overhaul of the EU Emissions Trading System in July. The presidency is now trying to bridge differences between national governments. Its draft, as described by Reuters, adjusts the balance between shielding European industry from overseas competitors and maintaining incentives to cut greenhouse gas emissions. Individual provisions may still change substantially before a common EU law emerges.

A different benchmark for free permits

Key facts

  • Legal status: Reuters described an Irish presidency compromise on 15 November; no final EU law has been adopted.
  • Benchmark proposal: use efficient installations accounting collectively for 10% of a sector's output, instead of the currently used 10% most efficient installations.
  • Smaller sites: plants receiving fewer than 5,000 free allowances during the previous allocation period would be exempt from a proposed decarbonisation investment-plan requirement.
  • Next stage: member states are due to discuss the text on 18 November; Council and Parliament positions and subsequent negotiations remain outstanding.

Installations covered by the EU carbon market must surrender allowances to cover their emissions. Some allowances are auctioned, while industries considered exposed to carbon leakage receive a share without charge. The objective is to reduce the incentive for companies to move production and associated emissions to jurisdictions with less demanding carbon rules. Free allocation is calculated with performance benchmarks that express emissions per unit of output. The Commission's overview confirms that existing benchmarks draw on the 10% most efficient installations in each sector.

The Irish draft would change the sample from a fixed share of installations to the most efficient sites together making 10% of the sector's production volume. Industrial groups argue that a handful of unusually efficient plants can otherwise exert disproportionate influence on an entire sector's benchmark. A volume-weighted approach could shift that influence, but the direction and size of the result for any particular German plant cannot be established without production data and final calculation rules.

Reuters also reports that the draft would spread benchmark cuts across annual steps rather than apply them in a single revision every five years. That would make the trajectory smoother, though the resulting allowance totals still depend on the law ultimately adopted. The Commission had already envisaged tighter benchmark reductions for the 2026-2030 allocation period. A slower schedule does not amount to removing emissions obligations.

How investment conditions could change

The proposal would affect when operators qualify for free permits as well as how many they receive. According to Reuters, plants allocated fewer than 5,000 free allowances over the preceding allocation period would not need to submit the new decarbonisation investment plans contemplated in the Commission proposal. This is a threshold based on the earlier allocation, not a blanket exemption for companies emitting 5,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide in a year.

For larger facilities, the presidency would release the final 20% of free allocation when construction starts on an eligible decarbonisation project. The Commission's proposed rule would wait until completion. Earlier release could help companies finance expensive equipment before it begins operating, but could also delay the point at which finished investment is demonstrated. Neither effect has yet been measured under this unfinished proposal.

The compromise would also broaden scope for pooled investments across industrial clusters and supply chains. Reuters reports clarification that certain heat-pump projects connected to district-heating networks could qualify. For major industrial regions, these mechanisms matter because a single site's emissions may depend on infrastructure shared with neighbouring plants. But no company gains an enforceable entitlement solely from this draft.

Why the separate 12 November agreement matters

On 12 November the Council and European Parliament announced a narrower provisional agreement concerning free allocations calculated under heat and fuel benchmarks. The Council put its proposed 2026-2030 cushion at about 121 million allowances, comprising 88 million already in the Commission approach, a further 28 million, and a dedicated five-million reserve. The deal still requires formal endorsement and adoption; it is not the same document as the broader Irish compromise.

Both files concern industrial competitiveness, but they address different parts of the allowance system and are at different legislative stages. Combining the figures with the presidency's new proposals would give a misleading impression that a single final package had been agreed.

The presidency told Reuters it was seeking agreement on the ETS review at the December Environment Council. Even if EU governments settle their position then, the European Parliament must establish its own mandate before the institutions can negotiate final legislation. Until that process is completed, the existing rules remain the relevant legal baseline.

← Back to the homepage